by Barbara West
Barbara West is a retired hospice and wound-care nurse who works part-time as a swim instructor. Living and working with migrant women and children on the Franco-Brittanic border led her to anti-deportation work at home, specifically with the Coalition to Stop Avelo Airlines. Contemplation of U.S. border policy now compels her to support Indigenous sovereignty.
Writing this piece has been hard. Anti-fossil-fuel activism is so important to me and to our world, and Third Actors are playing such an important role, that it seems disloyal to question our work.
I’m eager to jump in with both feet, but … I’m starting to learn about Indigenous sovereignty and my potential role as a white ally. And I’m spending more time in conversations led by people of color. So I’m learning a different view of the climate crisis, one that departs from what I hear in “mainstream” conversations where people of color are rarely in leadership roles. According to this new-to-me view, the climate crisis is being used to justify the next round of colonial extractivism: the race for transition minerals.
I want to honor my family and friends who work in electrification and renewable energy. I want to honor fellow Third Actors for our shared anti-fossil-fuel activism! I understand that as activists, we may hesitate to speak out about this issue, for fear of impeding an urgently needed transition to renewable energy. Nonetheless, I’m asking my readers to pause, now, and listen to Indigenous voices.
Thea Riofrancos’ Extraction: The Frontiers of Green Capitalism helps us take this pause. A long-time expert on mining in South America, she now studies lithium mining worldwide. She visits Indigenous leaders in communities affected by lithium mining in North and South America, Europe, and beyond. She writes:
“We can start by demanding supply chains organized around justice for everyone they touch, rather than profits for just a few. …[S]upply chains … connect Indigenous land defenders and urban transit users, workers manufacturing e-bikes and battery recycling advocates, bus drivers and avid cyclists, and climate activists and promoters of dense, walkable cities and towns. These communities, workers, and advocates are already bound together by the global operations of green capitalism–and in many cases, are already organizing locally. What would it take for them to join hands and fight for globally just supply chains, together?”
So here I am, in Corvallis, Oregon. My girlfriend and I fit the bill for “avid cyclists.” We live in a remodeled bungalow near the downtown of a “walkable city,” so we don’t use our car to buy groceries, attend yoga classes, concerts, or women’s basketball games. We don’t have a driveway, so we carefully lay an extension cord across the sidewalk to charge our Volkswagen ID.4.
I felt self-conscious driving this car, with its large long-range battery, to attend my first Annual Gathering of the Coalition to Dismantle the Doctrine of Discovery in August. I had read books by Coalition co-founders Sarah Augustine and Sheri Hostetler, so I knew their argument that a large, individually-owned EV is worse for the environment than an efficient gasoline-powered car. But, when I confided this to a long-time Coalition member, he reassured me I wouldn’t be judged, “I’m driving an EV too, and I’ve got solar panels on my roof. It’s hard to know what’s the right thing to do, so we’re all just figuring this out as we go along.”
Thanks to my recent learning from the Coalition’s Gathering, and recent interactions with Native artists, historians, authors, water-protectors, and their allies, I’m tackling the way my retirement savings are invested–a step that Third Act has actively encouraged. My previous financial advisor didn’t support my efforts to divest from harmful mining. So I’m now working with a new advisor who supports my goals.
To be sure, many white climate activists are quick to acknowledge the disproportionate impact of transition mineral mining on Indigenous Peoples. They argue that, as recycling improves and green tech becomes more efficient, we’ll only need another 25 years or so of mining. Unlike fossil fuels, renewable energy doesn’t require continuous inputs in the long run. Bill McKibben sums up this argument well in Here Comes the Sun: A Last Chance for the Climate and a Fresh Chance for Civilization
“There’s real harm that will come to real places and real people as we build out this new energy future. And so for me the question becomes how that harm compares with the ongoing harm of our present system. …
In a fair world, the people of Xianjiang and Inner Mongolia and Thacker Pass would get to make these decisions on their own, and decide for themselves what happens next. But we don’t live in a fair world – we live in a world that’s very rapidly tipping toward hell, a hell that will be hardest on precisely the people with the least power. Only moving fast can head off that hell, but moving fast means, inevitably, carelessness. It’s a hard call; I’m so scared of the climate crisis that I may bend too far.”
Bending too far, out of panic, is exactly what many Indigenous leaders believe that “mainstream” environmentalists are doing. Augustine and Hostetler put forth this argument in their book So That We & Our Children May Live:
“Our current, extractive economy is doing what it was designed to do. If we use an extractive economy to fight climate change, we will simply change what we extract: minerals rather than fossil fuels. The purpose will remain the same: to extract. If we want our economy to do something else–for instance, to ensure the well-being of families and communities, which include all life forms on planet Earth…then we need to build an economy designed to do that.”
For many European-Americans like me, most landscapes are, on some level, replaceable. We’re descended from people who simply move – every decade, or century, or two – when local conditions become unfavorable.
Indigenous people, by definition, are committed to the place of their ancestors – a commitment that emerges from a long-term relationship with a particular land, not for centuries, but for millennia. Or even time immemorial. In an Indigenous worldview, land is inherently sacred. Any particular piece of land is not interchangeable with some other, new, “unspoiled” landscape, even if the community has already been dislocated by colonizing forces.
It isn’t viable for Indigenous peoples living near transition mineral mining sites to give up “just one more” piece of sacred land, to get through “just another twenty-five years” of mining-for-profit. And, if we’re willing to look closely, we can see that such sacrifices are equally unviable for the rest of us. Accepting this trade-off won’t actually create the world we, activists of European ancestry, want for ourselves and our descendants either. When extractivism and colonialism are taken to their logical extremes, situations like the Donald Trump presidency result.
Here’s what I’m asking of you, my fellow anti-fossil-fuel activists who are, like me, descended from Europeans: might you be willing to apply the urgency you feel about climate change to spend time in movement spaces led by people of color? I invite you to join in my discomfort as I’m signing up for trainings, learning to overcome communication and thought patterns embedded in white supremacy culture, such as perfectionism, defensiveness, paternalism and…sense of urgency.
Fortunately, many organizations are tackling this challenge: Apache Stronghold, The Coalition to Dismantle the Doctrine of Discovery, Earthworks, IRMA, ICCR, The Tallgrass Institute, and now the Climate and Community Institute, of which Riofrancos is Strategic Co-Director. You can hear Riofrancos discuss her new book in an interview with climate journalist Rachel Donald in this YouTube interview. Or sign up here to join an Earthworks live online discussion on Dec. 17 at 3 PM ET/12 PM PT. Let’s discover together how to transition away from fossil fuels without perpetuating another cycle of colonialism.
Our old solar panels failed a few years ago. Our roof is small, and our energy use is so low it didn’t make financial sense to replace them. But, now that we’ve learned how to thread the charging cable across our sidewalk, my girlfriend wants to install new panels. “What do you think, Barbara?”
I don’t know what decision I would make on my own, but I respect her choice to move forward. The new panels will be up by next February. I don’t know which mines the minerals in them will have come from. But I’m hoping that, by February, my retirement savings won’t be enriching whichever company it was.
I recently learned of a call for white allies to participate in wintertime prayerful camping at Oak Flat, AZ (Chi’chil Biłdagoteel), where Apache Stronghold has been protecting sacred land from the Resolution Copper mine for the past 11 years. In addition to our Volkswagen ID.4, we own an old gasoline-powered Dodge Caravan. And we have a portable solar panel and battery with enough power to run an electric blanket. So I’ll soon be driving 20 hours south for three weeks of winter camping.
I look forward to meeting new people, being uncomfortable, and practicing some antidotes to my old cultural patterns such as… slowing down.
Further Reading
Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility (ICCR), June 2024, The Importance and Risks of Transition Minerals in Building a Just Transition by Julie Wokaty
Kalantzakos Sophia. 2025. “From Fossil Fuels to ‘Green Capitalism’: the Dilemmas of a Just Energy Transition” Nature 646(8084):279-280. doi: 10.1038/d41586-025-03224-z
Oxfam, September 22, 2023, “Recharging Community Consent: Mining Companies, Battery Minerals, and the Battle to Break From the Past,”